Corporations and Companies
3 tips to manage risk in legal writing - removing ambiguity
1. Crimes against the English language
Poor drafting is a crime against the English language.
A defendant once argued that no charge had been made against him because the wording included such poor grammar. He used an English teacher as a witness. The presiding judge noted that the documentation was "grammatically unintelligible"!
2. When things go really wrong
An Australian case, Alstom Ltd v Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd & Anor (no. 7), is a heavy reminder of the importance of correct and unambiguous legal drafting and words.
In his judgment, Justice Bleby stated that even "if the parties had spent a tiny fraction of the costs of this litigation on competent legal advice in the drafting of this contract, this case might never have arisen".
3. Warning signs
- If a pronoun could refer to more than one person, repeat the name of the person rather than use a pronoun in this instance
- Use the present tense to avoid reader confusion
- Use a parallel sentence structure, particularly when writing lists
- Use gender neutral terminology, e.g. "firefighter" rather than "fireman"
- Aim for short sentences containing one idea and short paragraphs containing only interlinked ideas.
Read how proofreading failures are creating risks for firms and their clients, and denying extra revenue.
39